Analytical Review of Theories of Divine Forgiveness from the Point of View of Orthodox Theology

Authors

  • Kreidich Alexander, Priest Moscow Theological Academy

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.31802/GB.2024.55.4.005

Keywords:

forgiveness, redemption, reconciliation, pardon, properties of God, guilt, duty

Abstract

The The article provides an overview of modern theories about divine forgiveness. To date, in Orthodox theology the phenomenon of Divine forgiveness is not considered separately. Within the framework of the theory, from the point of view of Orthodox thought, God's forgiveness is considered in the context of the theme of salvation and redemption, which determines the essence of the Orthodox view of forgiveness in the form of soteriological images and makes it possible to compare and contrast the Orthodox view of forgiveness with the theories of forgiveness of representatives of heterodoxy. The analytical review shows a tendency to avoid direct analogy with human forgiveness and identification with other concepts. Researchers seek to find a way to combine the temporality of the analogy of interpersonal forgiveness with the attributes of Divine forgiveness — eternity, God’s omniscience and goodness. In this regard, theories of a normative, legal nature seem more consistent, which, in turn, have their own shortcomings: they introduce distance in divine-human relations. Comparative and comparative analysis shows that any of the theories focuses on one or another aspect of forgiveness, which does not reflect the depth of the soteriological meaning of Divine forgiveness. In this regard, the Orthodox view of God’s forgiveness in the form of images that originate from the Holy Scripture does not lose its relevance.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Author Biography

Kreidich Alexander, Priest, Moscow Theological Academy

MA in Theology, PhD student of the Moscow Theological Academy

Holy Trinity-St. Sergius Lavra, Sergiev Posad 141312, Russia

krejdich94@yandex.ru

References

Basilius Caesariensis. Enarratio in prophetam Isaiam [Dub.] // PG. T. 30. Col. 117–668.

Gregorius Nyssenus. De creatione hominis sermo alter (recensio C) // Gregorii Nysseni opera / ed. H. Hörner. Leiden: Brill, 1972. P. 41a–72a.

Joannes Chrysostomus. In Genesim (homilia 55) // PG. T. 54. Col. 479–486.

Theodoretus Cyrrhensis. Interpretatio epistulae I ad Timotheum // PG. T. 82. Col. 788–829.

Василий Великий, свт. Беседа вторая о человеке // Василий Великий, свт. Творения: [в 2 т.]. Т. 1: Догматико-полемические творения. Экзегетические сочинения. Беседы. Москва: Сибирская благозвонница, 2009. С. C. 305–315.

Василий Великий, свт. Толкование на пророка Исаию // Василий Великий, свт. Творения: [в 2 т.]. Т. 1: Догматико-полемические творения. Экзегетические сочинения. Беседы. Москва: Сибирская Благозвонница, 2012. С. 611–865.

Ефрем Сирин, св. [96.] О покаянии // Ефрем Сирин, св. Творения. Т. 3. Москва: Русский издательский центр имени Святого Василия Великого, 2014. С. 165–216.

Иоанн Златоуст, свт. О покаянии (беседа 7) // Творения святого отца нашего Иоанна Златоуста, архиеп. Константинопольского в русском переводе: [в 12 т.]. Т. 2. Кн. 1. Санкт-Петербург: СПбДА, 1896. C. 358–374.

Иоанн Златоуст, свт. Беседы на книгу Бытия 55 // Творения святого отца нашего Иоанна Златоуста, архиеп. Константинопольского в русском переводе: [в 12 т.]. Т. 4. Кн.1. Санкт-Петербург: СПбДА, 1898. С. 586–595.

Феодорит Кирский, блж. Толкование на Первое послание Тимофею // Феодорит Кирский, блж. Творения / ред. А. И. Сидорова. Москва: Паломник, 2003. (Библиотека отцов и учителей Церкви; т. 12). С. 576–606.

Апресян Р. Г. Прощение // Новая философская энциклопедия: [в 4 т.] / ред. В. С. Степина, А. А. Гусейнова, А. П. Огурцова, Г. Ю. Семигина. Т. 3. Москва: Мысль, 2010. С. 381.

Новая Женевская учебная Библия / ред. В. А. Цорна. [Bielefeld]: Hänssler-Verlag, 1998.

Annas J. The Sage in Ancient Philosophy // Anthropine Sophia: studi di filologia e storiografia filosofica in memoria di Gabriele Giannantoni / ed. F. Alesse. Naple: Bibliopolis, 2008. (Elenchos, 50). P. 11–27.

Blustein J. M. Forgiveness and Remembrance: Remembering Wrongdoing in Personal and Public Life. New York (N. Y.): Oxford University Press, 2014.

Brien A. Can God Forgive Us Our Trespasses? // Sophia. 1989. Vol. 28 (2). Р. 35–42.

Craig W. L. Divine Forgiveness as Legal Pardon // Used by Permission of The Philosophy of Forgiveness. Vol. IV: Christian Perspectives on Forgiveness / ed. G. L. Bock. Wilmington (Del.): Vernon Press, 2010. P. 1–22.

Drabkin D. The Nature of God’s Love and Forgiveness // Religious Studies. 1993. Vol. 29 (2). P. 231–238.

Garrard E., McNaughton D. In Defence of Unconditional Forgiveness // Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society. 2002. Vol. 103 (1). Р. 39–60.

Geuras D. In Defense of Divine Forgiveness: A Response to David Londey // Sophia. 1992. Vol. 31 (1–2). Р. 65–77.

Hughes P. M. What is Involved in Forgiving? // The Journal of Value Inquiry. 1993. Vol. 27. P. 331–350.

Londey D. Can God Forgive Us Our Trespasses? // Sophia. 1986. Vol. 25 (1). P. 4–10.

Minas A. C. God and Forgiveness // The Philosophical Quarterly. 1975. Vol. 25 (99). P. 138–150.

Murphy J. G., Hampton J. Forgiveness and Mercy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1988.

Murphy J. G. Getting Even: Forgiveness and Its Limits. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2003.

Nelkin D. Freedom and Forgiveness // Free Will and Moral Responsibility / ed. I. Haji, J. Caouette. Newcastle Upon Tyne: Cambridge Scholars Press, 2013. P. 165–188.

Scheiber K. May God Forgive? // Forgiveness and Truth: Explorations in Contemporary Theology / ed. A. McFadyen, M. Sarot. Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 2001. P. 173–180.

Strabbing J. T. Divine Forgiveness and Reconciliation // Faith and Philosophy. 2017. Vol. 34 (3). P. 272–297.

Stump E. Atonement. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2018. (Oxford Studies in Analytic Theology).

Swinburne R. Responsibility and Atonement. Oxford; New York (N. Y.): Oxford University Press, 1989.

The Bible and the Greeks / ed. C. H. Dodd. London: Hodder & Stoughton, 21954.

Tombs D. The Offer of Forgiveness // Journal of Religious Ethics. 2008. Vol. 36 (4). P. 587–593.

Twambley P. Mercy and Forgiveness // Analysis. 1976. Vol. 36 (2). P. 84–90.

Warmke B. Divine Forgiveness I: Emotion and Punishment-Forbearance Theories // Philosophy Compass. 2017. Vol. 12 (9). (e12440). P. 1–8.

Warmke B. Divine Forgiveness II: Reconciliation and Debt-Cancellation Theories // Philosophy Compass. 2017. Vol. 12 (9). (e12439). P. 1–9.

Williams S. N. Forgiveness, Compassion, and Northern Ireland: A Response to Nigel Biggar // Journal of Religious Ethics. 2008. Vol. 36 (4). P. 581–593.

Published

2024-12-20

How to Cite

(1)
Kreidich А. Analytical Review of Theories of Divine Forgiveness from the Point of View of Orthodox Theology. БВ 2024, 103-120.